Family of Calgary cyclist killed in crash frustrated by legal system after trial called off, charge dropped
The widow of a Calgary father of two hit and killed while biking home from work nearly two years ago says she is still waiting for justice in her husband’s death.
“That was one of the things we needed as a family was to go to the trial as painful as it would be because we’d be reliving it in detail, but we were prepared to do that just to have some of the questions answered,” said Lorraine Maggipinto, wife of Mike Maggipinto.
Maggipinto said she found out just days before the trial was supposed to begin for the driver, a woman in her 30s, it was called off.
The decision took her family completely by surprise.
“If you’re going to drop the charges, then take the time to invite us into your office and say this is what we have, show us. I don’t know if every family would like to see it but I know this family did, I think it would have helped.”
Mike Maggipinto was hit by a delivery truck while riding on 11 Street and 53 Avenue N.E. around 4:30 p.m. on Friday, July 26, 2019. The 51-year-old was pinned under the truck.
He was transported to hospital in life-threatening condition but later died.
How her husband came to be in harm’s way was one of the questions nagging at Maggipinto since the incident. Now, without a trial, it’s unlikely she will ever find out.
“You need to cross two lanes of traffic first before you reach the crosswalk. That question is like the elephant in the room. How did the driver not see him?” said Maggipinto.
'LENGTHY AND COMPLEX' INVESTIGATIONS
According to Calgary police, the investigation determined neither drugs, alcohol or excessive speed were factors.
“In consultation with the Crown prosecutor’s office, a charge of careless driving was laid against the driver of the truck in January 2020,” said the Calgary Police Service in a statement.
Police say investigations into fatal collisions are lengthy and complex. They often require a number of forensic reports which take six to nine months on average to be returned to investigators.
Prosecutor Thom Forsyth said a trial was scheduled to begin June 10, 2020. But with just six days to go, the charge of careless driving was stayed against the driver.
When a charge is stayed, the Crown has up to one year to revive the case if new evidence comes to light, although that rarely happens.
Forsyth said prior to the trial, the defence provided its own expert report on the collision. He said prosectors are required to assess and re-evaluate files on an ongoing basis to determine whether the case should continue.
“Following consultations with CPS and other members of the prosecution service, I concluded that there was no longer a reasonable likelihood of conviction in this matter and the prosecution ultimately entered a stay of proceedings,” said Forsythe in a statement to CTV News.
“The death of Mr. Maggipinto is a tragedy and our sympathies are with his family,” said Forsyth.
Maggipinto said it was important for her and her children now 17 and 20, for a judge to make a decision on the evidence and have the case go to a trial.
“There’s a lot of questions and we were not given any answers. We’re just supposed to accept that it’s done and move on? And trust me, it’s not easy to just move on.”
If someone is convicted of careless driving, under the Traffic Safety Act, the maximum penalty is a $2,000 fine.
“I would have preferred a conviction only because as it is now, Mike is completely to blame and I don’t believe that. There’s two people involved,” Maggipinto said. “If, in the end, the judge comes back with an acquittal, fine, at least we saw it through and it’s not just dropped.”
Maggipinto said her family is missing a huge piece of their puzzle – a husband of nearly 20 years, father and friend.
“There’s a huge void but we talk about him as much as we can…I miss everything about him.”
Calgary Top Stories
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
Last in the polls and amid climate crisis, Green Party leader defends record ahead of final election sprint
Green Party Leader Annamie Paul is defending her party's performance in the federal election campaign, with the party trailing in national support polling despite climate change being one of the top issues for voters, in a sit-down interview with CTV National News.
An Afghan journalist, who is now in Qatar, is telling the story of his escape from Afghanistan and his expectations for his life once he reunites with family in Canada.
With a fourth wave of the pandemic underway, provinces and territories are responding with a variety of restrictions. CTVNews.ca looks at what is and is not allowed in each jurisdiction.
A child under the age of 10, who Waterloo Region's medical officer of health said had underlying health conditions, has died due to COVID-19.
With 3 days left until election, O'Toole fixates on vote-splitters and deflects questions on his fate
With three days left in the 2021 federal election campaign and polling suggesting a Liberal win maybe the most likely outcome, Conservative Leader Erin O’Toole was laser-focused on one message Friday: a vote for any party other than his is a vote for Liberal Leader Justin Trudeau.
The B.C. government announced another 11 deaths related to COVID-19 on Friday, marking the deadliest 24 hours in the province since February.
An Afghan interpreter has been reunited with her family in Canada after they were able to board one of the last evacuation flights out of Kabul.
A California jury on Friday found multimillionaire real estate heir Robert Durst guilty of murdering his best friend Susan Berman in 2000, the first homicide conviction for a man suspected of killing three people in three states over the past 39 years.
Endorsements for Liberal Leader Justin Trudeau from former U.S. president Barack Obama and Hillary Clinton have raised questions about election interference. But according to the Canada Elections Act, a foreign citizen speaking about the Canadian election does not by itself constitute an instance of undue foreign influence.
Alberta reported more than 2,000 daily COVID-19 cases for the first time since May on Friday.
The term "triage" may be a scary one to hear, but Alberta's health authorities are preparing its staff and the public for the possibility of that extreme measure.
A 24-year-old mother and her 16-month-old were found dead in Hinton, Alta., RCMP said.
Anti-vaccine protesters allegedly entered multiple schools in B.C.'s Shuswap region Friday, prompting strong words from district officials.
It’s now been two weeks since the Vancouver Park Board and provincial officials erected a bright orange fence around Stanley Park to try and deal with aggressive coyotes.
Technically, it’s still summer, but Friday felt like winter. The rain fell hard on Southern Vancouver Island, where total precipitation was expected to be in the 35-millimetre range through the evening.
Almost 200 nurses rallied at Premier John Horgan’s constituency office Friday to demand an end to the chronic nursing shortage in B.C. hospitals and patient care facilities.
There are now 6,031 active cases of COVID-19 in B.C., including 700 active cases in the Vancouver Island region, according to the B.C. Health Ministry.
The cause of the tragic trailer fire in Millvale, N.S., that killed a family of six has been ruled accidental.
New Brunswick's jump in COVID-19 cases has overloaded the health-care system this week.
A supervisor at a Wendy's restaurant in Sydney, N.S., has pleaded guilty to sexual assault.
In the three weeks since Ontario unveiled its vaccine certificate program, Premier Doug Ford has been notably absent from the public eye, with the exception of videos posted to social media and a virtual address last week in Toronto.
Police believe the 25-year-old to be violent and advises the public not to approach him if located.
A shooting at a large gathering in Mississauga Friday evening left three people seriously injured, Peel police say.
An Ottawa councillor is demanding to know why so many school bus routes have been cancelled in the Kanata and Stittsville area this month, as school bus operators deal with a driver shortage.
SIU concludes Ottawa police officers won't face charges after police pursuit ends before east end crash
The Special Investigations Unit concluded the police pursuit was called off "well before" the suspect driver ran a red light and collided with the woman's vehicle.
As of 3:30 p.m. Friday, the earliest appointment available at the CHEO Community Assessment Clinic at Brewer Arena was Sunday morning.
A spokesperson for the hospital where he died said the man's condition 'deteriorated rapidly.' Friends identified him as Stefanos Govas, a 39-year-old athlete.
McGill University to require vaccine passport for libraries, but many still want it to be mandatory for classes
“The logic of it makes no sense. If you're going to do it in a library, why are you not doing it in a classroom?” said Richard Gold, a McGill University law professor.
In a statement to CTV News, the Lakeshore Hospital confirmed that two its operating rooms have had to shut down “in order to address the increase in COVID-19 cases in the ICU.”
Waterloo regional police are investigating after a man was found with injuries in a Kitchener apartment building lobby.
The Downtown Kitchener Ribfest and Craft Beer Show is welcoming guests at Victoria Park from Friday to Sunday after it was cancelled last year due to the pandemic.
Student union at Nipissing University launches safety tips for university students partying off campus
With recent sexual assault allegations at Western University, the Nipissing University Student Union is sharing safe partying tips on its social media platforms to offer advice to students.
Almost 10 months to the day that Const. Marc was killed, family, friends and even strangers will cycle both on Manitoulin Island and virtually Saturday.
Sault Ste. Marie's social services board has approved a plan to hire 10 new paramedics. The move is in response to a sharp increase in the number of calls to the city's paramedic services in recent months.
A restaurant that has been in operation in Winnipeg for 63 years is no more.
Winnipeggers might face some delays when driving on the Perimeter Highway Saturday.
Manitoba has recorded 88 new COVID-19 cases in Manitoba, along with one more death added to the total.
Seven more Saskatchewan residents have died after testing positive for COVID-19.
Regina vaccine clinic, rapid testing site dealing with influx of people following COVID-19 announcement
A COVID-19 vaccination clinic and a rapid testing site are dealing with a large amount of people, following Thursday’s announcement from the provincial government on plans to implement a proof of vaccination or a negative test policy.
The Saskatchewan Health Authority's Emergency Operations Centre directed leaders and care teams to move to a second phase of surge plans that include a temporary slowdown of elective procedures province-wide.
Saskatchewan’s far north COVID-19 case rate in the last seven days is sitting at 1,180 per 100,000 people – the highest across Canada.
As the province prepares to roll out proof of vaccination, some are concerned that the aging portion of Saskatchewan’s population may not be able to easily adapt to the QR code that is planned on being used.
Seven more Saskatchewan residents have died after testing positive for COVID-19.