MRU prof victim 'very disappointed' after Supreme Court upholds extreme intoxication defence
The Supreme Court of Canada has restored the acquittal of a Calgary man who consumed psilocybin — better known as magic mushrooms — before attacking a woman in her southwest home, and also ruled the law cannot bar the defence of extreme intoxication for violent offences.
A naked Matthew Brown broke into Janet Hamnett’s home in the early morning hours of Jan. 13, 2018, after consuming illegal, psychedelic drugs and alcohol.
Court heard Brown, an MRU student and former hockey captain, assaulted Hamnett with a broom handle, causing severe injuries to her arms and hands.
On Friday, the Supreme Court (SCC) delivered its decision to end Brown's criminal case in acquittal, also ruling "automatism," or a state of extreme intoxication, is an available, Charter-protected a defence for some crimes.
Hamnett, a professor at Mount Royal University with no prior connection to Brown, said in a statement to CTV News, "I am very disappointed with this decision, it is not about me at this stage."
"The Supreme Court basically said it's allowable to attack, hurt, and even kill someone, if the perpetrator is out of control due to drugs or alcohol that were most likely ingested intentionally and willingly," she said.
Hamnett added the decision offers no protection for innocent victims in favour of the assailants.
"Where is the justice in that? This opens a terrifying flood gate... and I fear for future victims," she said.
There is no civil case being brought against Brown.
EXTREME DEFENCE
Some legal experts say they too believe the decision will have a further impact on violent crimes involving drugs.
"The bottom line is that extreme intoxication is going to be a defence for certain offenses that it wasn't a defence for before. Such as manslaughter, assault and sexual assault," said Lisa Silver, an associate professor in the faculty of law at University of Calgary.
Silver adds the defence is meant to be used in extreme and rare cases when it can be proven "that a person is not even capable of forming the mental element required to commit the crime," and has lost choice or control over their actions.
The defense will not apply to impaired driving offences.
The SCC decision also said Parliament may want to enact a new law to hold extremely intoxicated people accountable for violent crimes, to protect vulnerable victims, particularly women and children.
Silver said if lawmakers do that, they should also include take into account addiction issues as substances can be consumed involuntarily.
CONSIDER THE SYSTEM
An organization called LEAF: Women's Legal Action and Education Fund, acted as an intervener in this case and said it was encouraged the SCC decision highlighted women's rights.
"What we see too often is that the criminal justice system fails survivors, particularly survivors of sexual violence, but really all forms of violence," said Kat Owens, a member of the legal team with LEAF.
"It's really important beyond thinking about what to add to the criminal code to think about how do we make this system work for people."
Owens says it is more important for the criminal justice system and the actors within it to fully understand this defence and carry out justice for women and girls.
NO 'FLOODGATES'
Sean Fagan, the criminal defence lawyer representing Brown, told CTV News both he and his client were pleased with the ruling.
"He still extends his apologies and remorse to the complainant in this matter, as he did at trial," said Fagan.
Fagan adds the decision will not "open the floodgates to intoxication defences" as the legal bar to prove they lost intent and control is very high.
"It doesn't change the fact that general levels of intoxication are not and have never been a defense to violent offences," said Fagan.
"This case dealt solely with the narrow window of extreme intoxication, basically, drug induced psychosis. Most individuals will have never even seen, let alone achieved a level of intoxication that is required for this defense, even at the most unruly of frat parties or NHL games."
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
'They needed people inside Air Canada:' Police announce arrests in Pearson gold heist
Police say one former and one current employee of Air Canada are among the nine suspects that are facing charges in connection with the gold heist at Pearson International Airport last year.
House admonishes ArriveCan contractor in rare parliamentary show of power
MPs enacted an extraordinary, rarely used parliamentary power on Wednesday, summonsing an ArriveCan contractor to appear before the House of Commons where he was admonished publicly and forced to provide answers to the questions MPs said he'd previously evaded.
Leafs star Auston Matthews finishes season with 69 goals
Auston Matthews won't be joining the NHL's 70-goal club this season.
Trump lawyers say Stormy Daniels refused subpoena outside a Brooklyn bar, papers left 'at her feet'
Donald Trump's legal team says it tried serving Stormy Daniels a subpoena as she arrived for an event at a bar in Brooklyn last month, but the porn actor, who is expected to be a witness at the former president's criminal trial, refused to take it and walked away.
Why drivers in Eastern Canada could see big gas price spikes, and other Canadians won't
Drivers in Eastern Canada face a big increase in gas prices because of various factors, especially the higher cost of the summer blend, industry analysts say.
Doug Ford calls on Ontario Speaker to reverse Queen's Park keffiyeh ban
Ontario Premier Doug Ford is calling on Speaker Ted Arnott to reverse a ban on keffiyehs at Queen's Park, describing the move as “needlessly” divisive.
'A living nightmare': Winnipeg woman sentenced following campaign of harassment against man after online date
A Winnipeg woman was sentenced to house arrest after a single date with a man she met online culminated in her harassing him for years, and spurred false allegations which resulted in the innocent man being arrested three times.
Woman who pressured boyfriend to kill his ex in 2000s granted absences from prison
A woman who pressured her boyfriend into killing his teenage ex more than a decade ago will be allowed to leave prison for weeks at a time.
Customers disappointed after email listing $60K Tim Hortons prize sent in error
Several Tim Horton’s customers are feeling great disappointment after being told by the company that an email stating they won a boat worth nearly $60,000 was sent in error.