Planned Alberta Bill of Rights amendment prompts criticism from legal expert
Alberta's plan to introduce legislation reaffirming the right to medical bodily autonomy this fall is being met with criticism from a legal expert who argues the right is already enshrined in the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms.
Premier Danielle Smith announced plans to amend the Alberta Bill of Rights in a video posted to social media on Tuesday morning.
When answering questions from reporters on Wednesday, she pointed to the COVID-19 Pandemic and vaccine mandates for government workers who were subsequently fired from their jobs for refusing to take the vaccine.
Despite the workers losing their jobs due to government requirements, they still had the bodily autonomy to make the conscious decision not to receive the vaccination.
"We've now had two judgments against us," said Smith. "It was grieved by the nurse's union and grieved by the Alberta union of provincial employees, and we lost, and we had to give compensation to the employees that were let go from their job because they refused a vaccine."
"Those would be two examples that I don't want to see happen again."
Smith admits that the commitment to reaffirm bodily autonomy was based on recommendations from the Public Health Emergencies Governance Review Panel's final report.
Preston Manning was the panel chair.
"He had a number of recommendations about how to improve things through the Alberta Bill of Rights, and one of them was to give more recognition to a person's right to make their own medical choices. So yes, I say that provision comes directly from a commitment I made," Smith said.
Alberta Health Minister Adriana LaGrange also referred to the report as part of what she calls "extensive engagement" throughout the pandemic.
"Albertans want to have the rights that they already have enshrined to be even further strengthened, and so that's what this bill will come forward with," she said.
When pressed further if she could give an example of bodily autonomy right infringements, LaGrange dodged the question.
"Again, I would rather just wait till we have the bill in front of you, and then you can actually see the wording in the bill, because you will see it was very much about strengthening the overall rights and freedoms," she added.
‘A signal to the anti-vax base'
Lorian Hardcastle, associate professor in the faculty of law in the Cumming School of Medicine at the University of Calgary, criticized the province for making vague statements.
"We already have that right under the Charter," Hardcastle said. "The right to life, liberty and security of the person, already protects medical autonomy."
"It isn't clear to me what the government is trying to accomplish here. If it is just a right to make medical choices, or if this instead is broader, and it could limit the ability of employers to acquire vaccines of health-care workers or limit the ability of the government to put in place public health measures."
Hardcastle went on to say that the LaGrange's "inability" to provide examples of the right being violated is telling.
"This is more of a political decision than one related to the protection of health-care rights itself.
"The government is not actually creating new legal rights, but rather sending a signal to the anti-vax members of their base who feel like they were grieved by what went on during Covid," she said.
"The concern, though, is what would happen in a future public health emergency? If this right is construed broadly in a future public health emergency, might long-term care facilities not be able to require vaccines? Might other employers not be able to require vaccines? Might the government actually tie its own hands in a public health emergency to put in place public health measures that are necessary at the time?"
Hardcastle says another issue also lies in the fact that the province plans to introduce legislation that can compel treatment of individuals experiencing addictions.
"So, it isn't clear how those two pieces of legislation will agree with one another, and potentially the 'compassionate care legislation,' as they're calling it, that could be subject to a charter challenge, but it actually could now potentially be subject to a challenge under the province's own Bill of Rights."
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
BREAKING Israeli airstrike kills at least 20 people including children at a school in central Gaza
An Israeli airstrike has killed at least 20 people including children at a school-turned-shelter in central Gaza, according to local hospitals.
Thousands of miles from home, Trudeau learns of dissension in his caucus
The free trade agreement with ASEAN is expected to be signed at the end of 2025. If Trudeau is pressured to step down, or if his government falls and loses the next election, Trudeau will not, as prime minister, be there to see the fruits of his labour.
Here's the dirt on the germiest items in your day-to-day life
Your home – considered to be one of the safest havens from all the external stresses – is filthy.
Trump suggests a protester may get 'the hell knocked out of her' by her parents
Former U.S. president Donald Trump called for a protester at one of his rallies to 'go back home to Mommy' to 'get the hell knocked out of her,' his latest instance of using violent language when confronted by demonstrators.
Court untangles 'bizarre mess' that allowed Vancouver duplex owner to pay off mortgage after foreclosure, sale
A B.C. Supreme Court judge has ruled on a case she describes as a "bizarre mess" in a decision issued earlier this week.
Historic Jersey Shore amusement park closes after generations of family thrills
The historic Jersey Shore amusement park has closed amid financial woes made worse by COVID-19 and Superstorm Sandy.
Should men and women eat different breakfasts? Study suggests they should
The study, which uses a mathematical model, indicates that men and women may benefit from different breakfast choices to optimize metabolism and potentially aid weight management.
Liberals announce new campaign director amid new push to oust Trudeau
The Liberal Party has named Andrew Bevan as its new national campaign director for the next federal election. The announcement comes as party continues to face lagging polls and as party leader Justin Trudeau is facing new pressure to step aside.
Man with loaded gun arrested at checkpoint near Donald Trump's weekend rally in Southern California
A Nevada man with a shotgun, a loaded handgun and ammunition in his vehicle was arrested at a security checkpoint outside Donald Trump's rally Saturday night in the Southern California desert, authorities said Sunday.