Political interference alleged in assessment hearings in Matthew de Grood case
Alberta's high court is being asked to overturn a review board decision relating to the stabbing deaths of five young people at a Calgary house party on the grounds the former provincial justice minister interfered.
The lawyer for Matthew de Grood, in a filing to Alberta's Court of Appeal, says her client was denied a fair Alberta Review Board hearing last fall, and argues former minister Doug Schweitzer's statements and actions played a role.
"The justice minister's comments and his direct recruitment of certain individuals to the Review Board has created an apprehension of bias that affected the fairness of his 2022 annual review,'' lawyer Jacqueline Petrie argued in a document filed Thursday.
"The Review Board, and more directly the chair of his hearing, did not treat (de Grood) in an impartial and procedurally fair manner.
"The disposition the board made was not reflective of the actual risk he poses but rather is the result of political interference and public pressure not to discharge him or grant him the privileges he seeks.''
A spokesperson for Alberta Justice provided CTV News with the following statement:
"The Alberta Review Board is composed of psychiatrists, legal and public members, who operate and make decisions independent of government.
"When recruiting and appointing to positions, candidates are considered depending on the experience, competencies, and attributes required for the role. Applicants are screened for conflict of interest prior to appointment," it added.
"As has historically been the case, the justice minister selects potential candidates to be appointed and will bring them forward to cabinet for approval. Members of the Alberta Review Board are appointed by order-in-council with the appointments posted on the Alberta.ca website.
"It would be inappropriate to comment further, considering Mr. de Grood remains under the care of Alberta Hospital Edmonton and this matter is still before the board."
Schweitzer did not immediately return requests for comment.
NOT CRIMINALLY RESPONSIBLE
De Grood, 31, was found not criminally responsible in 2016 for the killings two years earlier of Zackariah Rathwell, Jordan Segura, Kaitlan Perras, Josh Hunter and Lawrence Hong because he was suffering from schizophrenia at the time.
Since then, he has been under supervision and his case is reviewed by the Alberta Review Board yearly to determine his mental state and whether he can transition further back into the community while not jeopardizing public safety.
Schweitzer, who has since retired from politics, weighed in on de Grood's case in his role as justice minister in October 2019 after the panel granted de Grood freedom to transition from institutional care to a supervised Edmonton group home setting along with unsupervised passes to the surrounding area.
On April 15, 2014, de Grood killed 23-year-old Kaiti Perras, 21-year-old Zackariah Rathwell, 22-year-old Jordan Segura, 23-year-old Josh Hunter and 27-year-old Lawrence Hong. He was found not criminally responsible.Schweitzer at the time took to Twitter to say he has heard from Albertans "frustrated and disturbed'' over the decision and said he would lobby the federal government to review the release rules while pursuing options to ensure the board processes "respect victims.''
Soon after, the chair of the review board resigned and, said Petrie, in the months that followed Schweitzer appointed new panel members that "were politically aligned with the provincial government, '' which she said raise reasonable doubts on whether the board could be considered fair and impartial on de Grood's case.
A year after the 2019 decision, the review board, with its new chair and members, reversed the freedoms granted de Grood. That decision was later overturned by the Court of Appeal on the grounds it was unreasonable and not supported by the evidence.
Last fall, the review board declared him a serious threat to public safety and said he must be kept under constant supervision in an Edmonton group home.
Petrie argues evidence at the latest hearing showed de Grood was stable under medication, has family support and is a low-risk to reoffend. She said the board failed to assess the evidence properly or apply the proper legal tests in making its decision.
Matthew de Grood
De Grood's 2016 trial heard evidence he attacked the individuals at a party, held to mark the end of the school year, believing the devil was talking to him and a war was about to begin that signalled the end of the world.
He told officers he knew what he did was "atrocious'' but he was killing Medusas and werewolves.
'FIVE PEOPLE WERE KILLED'
Gregg Perras, the father of Kaitlan Perras, offered a comment on the request by De Grood's lawyer.
"Number one I don't think it should be politicized that five people were killed," he said. "I think it's grasping at straws.
"That scares us," Perras said, continuing. "And it should scare the public that an absolute discharge should be if ever granted.
"In our opinions, we're biased," said. "It should never be granted but it should be something that's considered way down the line, not in the current context of what his lawyer is suggesting with this political interference that she's alleging.
"This time," he added, "it seems far more scary to us that his lawyers decided to make it political and also angling that he deserves an absolute discharge."
The Crown deadline for responding is Feb. 28.
This report by The Canadian Press was first published Feb. 3, 2023.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories

Federal dental insurance program to be phased in over 2024, benefits to start in May
The new federal dental insurance plan will be phased in gradually over 2024, with the first claims likely to be processed in May, government officials said ahead of a formal announcement scheduled for Monday morning.
'We're trying not to break down': Sask. family desperate to find their loved one last seen in Toronto
The family of 39-year-old Lesley Sparvier has been trying to find and locate her after she left home on foot in Kahkewistahaw First Nation, Sask. on Nov. 28.
Buckingham Palace releases this year’s Christmas card
Buckingham Palace released an image of the Christmas card that King Charles III and Queen Camilla will be sending out this year.
Iowa man arrested in the death of a Nebraska Catholic priest
A man has been arrested in the stabbing death of a Catholic priest who was attacked over the weekend in a church rectory in a small Nebraska community, authorities said.
The Université de Moncton will not be getting a new name
The board of New Brunswick's Universite de Moncton has decided not to change the school's name despite concerns about its connection to a problematic historical figure.
Trump says he won't testify Monday at his New York fraud trial and sees no need to appear again
Donald Trump said Sunday he has decided against testifying for a second time at his New York civil fraud trial, posting on social media that he "VERY SUCCESSFULLY & CONCLUSIVELY" testified last month and saw no need to appear again.
Saskatchewan is a safe space to buy 'sustainable oil,' Scott Moe says
Saskatchewan Premier Scott Moe is working hard to use a global climate change conference as an opportunity to market the province’s non-renewable resources.
LCBO reveals what Ontarians drank the most this year
When it came to what Ontarians brought home during their liquor runs at the LCBO, the company said customers went for options that gave them more bang for their buck.
Al Gore calls UAE hosting COP28 'ridiculous,' slams oil CEO appointed to lead climate talks
Climate advocate and former Vice President Al Gore on Sunday called into question the decision to hold the COP28 climate talks in the United Arab Emirates, a leading producer of the world’s oil.