Two Alberta First Nations want court to allow appeal of decision on coal mine
A second Alberta First Nation wants a court to allow it to appeal a review board's decision that an open-pit coal mine in the Rocky Mountains is not in the public interest.
The Stoney Nakoda Nation has filed a request with the Alberta Court of Appeal to appeal the decision that blocks the development of Benga Mining's proposed Grassy Mountain project near the town of Crowsnest Pass in southwestern Alberta.
“The (panel) did not properly assess the impact that rejecting the project would have on Stoney Nakoda Aboriginal and treaty rights and economic interests related to the accommodation of those rights,” says the Stoney application.
The Piikani First Nation filed a similar request last week, as did Benga Mining.
Two other southern Alberta First Nations, the Kainai and the Siksika, are not filing appeals.
“Kainai will not participate in Benga's appeal,” said a statement from the band.
“Kainai remains concerned about coal projects in the Crowsnest Pass region, and in particular on the headwaters of the Oldman River watershed, and will continue to oppose any other efforts to pursue coal mines in the region.”
The Siksika council made a similar statement.
“As the government of Alberta has not addressed Siksika's concerns about coal projects in the Crowsnest Pass region, Siksika will continue to oppose any other efforts to pursue coal mines,” it said.
In June, a joint federal-provincial environmental review panel decided the project should not proceed because the threat it posed to southern Alberta's water supply was too great for the economic benefits it would have created.
The mine, the company said, would create about 500 jobs during two years of construction and 400 more over its 23-year life. The company said it would pay $1.7 billion in royalties and $35 million in municipal taxes over that time.
But the panel concluded the mine posed too great an environmental risk to the headwaters of the Oldman River from selenium, an element commonly found in coal mines that, in large doses, is toxic to fish.
The panel cast doubt on Benga's promises to capture up to 98 per cent of selenium released. It said Benga's assumptions were overly optimistic, its reclamation plans vague and its economic projections overstated.
The review panel also concluded the mine would damage ecosystems and impair the cultural and physical heritage of local First Nations.
But the Stoney Nakoda Nation, which has signed an impact and benefits agreement with Benga, said it was never asked.
The Piikani said that the panel relied on a ruling from an Alberta government office that said consultation had been adequate. As a result, it didn't dig deeply enough into how blocking the mine would affect the First Nation.
Piikani Chief Stanley Grier said the review panel shouldn't have relied solely on the provincial office to get the band's perspective.
“We were never consulted by the joint review panel directly,” he said. “Nobody speaks on behalf of the Piikani Nation but ourselves.”
He acknowledged some Piikani members oppose the mine, but said chief and council held extensive meetings with band members and elders before making its decision.
“I respect them, but that does not change the chief and council's decision.”
He said the panel's reliance on the provincial office to ensure the Piikani were consulted was disrespectful not only to his nation, but other First Nations as well.
Grier called the 25-year projected life of the mine a generational opportunity for his people that could now be lost.
“That is a legacy opportunity for us.”
Latasha Calf Robe of the Niitsitapi Water Protectors - a group opposing coal development - said concern about the projects among the membership of all First Nations in the region is growing.
“I would say we're pushing toward 70 per cent,” she said.
Benga said the panel treated it unfairly by telling the company it had filed a complete application with supporting documents, then concluding its environmental information was inadequate.
It also said the panel ignored relevant environmental data while accepting evidence the company calls “non-expert and unfounded opinion.”
The Piikani and Benga applications are to be heard Sept. 9, while the Stoney appeal is to be heard on Sept. 22.
This report by The Canadian Press was first published July 22, 2021
Calgary Top Stories
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
The story of how the groundbreaking mRNA vaccines were developed to help the world fight COVID-19 is a fascinating one — but it’s been missing a key part, according to a scientist who says a fundamental aspect of these vaccines was originally developed by a small team in Canada.
The centre-left Social Democrats have won the biggest share of the vote in Germany's national election, beating outgoing Chancellor Angela Merkel's centre-right Union bloc in a closely fought race.
Canada's ambassador to the U.S. says the Chinese government initiated the dialogue to release Michael Kovrig and Michael Spavor, noting that the U.S. did not make the freedom of the two Canadians a condition of the deferred prosecution agreement reached with Huawei executive Meng Wanzhou.
'Moulin Rouge! The Musical,' a jukebox adaptation of Baz Luhrmann's hyperactive 2001 movie, won the best new musical crown at the Tony Awards on a Sunday night when Broadway looked back to honour shows shuttered by COVID-19, mourn its fallen and also look forward to welcoming audiences again.
The Rolling Stones launched their pandemic-delayed "No Filter" tour Sunday at the Dome at America's Center in St. Louis without their drummer of nearly six decades.
The Conservative Party is facing internal strife as some insiders want to see Erin O'Toole ousted as leader, while newly elected MPs hope for some semblance of unity.
The Americans won back the Ryder Cup and perhaps a whole lot more Sunday, sending a strong message to Europe with a powerful performance from their youngest team in history.
Japan's ruling party votes on Wednesday for the country's next prime minister in an election that has turned into the most unpredictable race since Shinzo Abe made a surprise comeback almost a decade ago, defeating a popular rival in a runoff.
A team of scientists have developed a 3D-printed vaccine patch as a painless way to immunize without the use of a needle while offering a better immune response, according to the study.
The redrawn boundaries attempt to better balance the population of each ward and shed the traditional numbering system for Indigenous ward names.
The City of Edmonton's 12 wards have new Indigenous names and re-designed boundaries.
Nakota Isga has three candidates in the 2021 municipal election, including incumbent Andrew Knack.
Police and emergency crews responded early Sunday morning to a serious crash at the University of British Columbia’s Point Grey campus.
A new Vancouver Police Department initiative aims to improve communication between police and people who are deaf and hard of hearing.
British Columbians who've been thinking about adopting a new pet can do so for half price this week.
The B.C. government has extended rules limiting the fees that food delivery companies can charge that were originally put in place to help restaurants cope with the COVID-19 pandemic.
BC Highway Patrol is asking witnesses to come forward after a fatal single-vehicle crash in the Mid-Island Friday night.
British Columbians who've been thinking about adopting a new pet can do so for half price this week.
Dalhousie University says it's taking disciplinary action against students who took part in a rowdy party Saturday night that drew thousands to the city's south end.
New Brunswick is announcing another COVID-19-related death, as well as 82 new cases on Sunday.
Nova Scotia is scheduled to move into Phase 5 of its recovery plan on October 4 if all goes according to plan.
A midtown Toronto restaurant says it will not accept unvaccinated guests inside, even if they have a medical exemption.
A 14-year-old boy riding his bicycle was killed in a collision with a vehicle in East Gwillimbury Sunday afternoon, York Regional Police say.
Ontario's daily COVID-19 case counts are lower than what many experts had expected by now, and while they point to a number of factors for the relative relief, they say now is not the time to ease up on those measures.
Approximately 35 per cent of the 474 active cases in Ottawa right now are in those under 19-years-old.
The high vaccination rate comes as the Ottawa Catholic School Board prepares to approve a new mandatory COVID-19 vaccination policy for all staff, visitors and volunteers on Tuesday.
Ottawa Public Health is reporting 79 more people in the city have tested positive for COVID-19.
Baseball fans in Montreal will want to look on a right field wall of Tropicana Field during the MLB playoffs when the Tampa Bay Rays play, as a new sign will feature future plans the team has to split regular season games.
A man was found dead with bullet wounds Sunday afternoon following a shooting in Montreal's Rivière-des-Prairies–Pointe-aux-Trembles borough.
The CTV Montreal News at 6 p.m. has been pre-empted due to NFL football. Watch the broadcast above.
‘It was much more tame than normal’: Gathering restrictions temper homecoming weekend in Waterloo Region
Thousands of students and alumni came through Waterloo Region over the weekend to partake in homecomings at nearby universities, and Waterloo’s mayor said COVID-19 restrictions appear to have been obeyed.
A man from Cambridge ran 132 kilometres from Guelph to Goderich to raise money for the Heart & Stroke Foundation of Canada.
About 40 Canadian Army Reserve soldiers from Guelph’s 11th Field Artillery Regiment have made a quarry in Puslinch Township their temporary training ground.
A special structure is going up behind the Anishinabek Discovery Centre in Sault Ste. Marie. A group of volunteers gathered over the weekend to build a teaching lodge, which will serve as a centre for traditional learning.
Four females from a Saskatchewan First Nation passed through Sudbury on Sunday as they bike to Ottawa for their 'Honoring Our Children Journey.'
Fall Fun Days at Aidie Creek Gardens in Englehart, Ont. is all about being out on the farm.
Puck drop for the start of the Winnipeg Jets preseason at the Canada Life Centre isn't just exciting news for hockey fans but for restaurants in the downtown area too.
A man is dead after being shot in the North End early Sunday morning.
As Canada prepares to recognize the first National Day for Truth and Reconciliation Thursday, the desire to hear from residential school survivors has soared across the country.
Saskatchewan’s Ministry of Health reported 552 new COVID-19 cases and 436 recoveries, bringing active cases in the province to a record-breaking 4,864.
For more than 25 years a woman in Balgonie, Sask. has been hosting an annual fundraiser for cancer research around the Terry Fox Run, with a new twist on the event.
On Sunday, the Saskatchewan Health Authority declared outbreaks at Chief Whitecap, Ernest Lindner and W.P. Bate Schools, according to a news release from Saskatoon Public Schools (SPS).
After scorching temperatures this past summer, farmers are wrapping up their harvest with the majority of them facing lower than expected yields.