Alberta's UCP government used 'false narratives' to justify safe supply policies: commentary
A new commentary suggests the Government of Alberta purposely pushed false narratives around public safety to scale down safe supply in the province.
The commentary, titled Safer supply and political interference in medical practice: Alberta's Narcotics Transition Services, is published in International Journal of Drug Policy.
The commentary's statements revolve around the election of the United Conservative Party (UCP) in 2019, and the ensuing policy shift away from harm reduction towards an abstinence-focused, recovery-oriented system of care.
The commentary concludes that the UCP caucus' strong opposition to all forms of prescribed safe supply has led to the government prioritizing ideology over evidence.
It claims that at various times "prescribers were framed as harmful and requiring increased restrictions," and "people who use drugs were framed as criminals and a danger to the public."
The narratives, according to the commentary, allowed for "political inference in medical decision-making."
Regulating policy
In October 2022, Alberta effectively banned safe supply in the province by amending the Mental Health Services Protection Regulation.
The changes prohibited prescribing of safer supply in most clinical settings in Alberta,and made it so all dosing had to be witnessed.
The decision was at least partially informed by findings from a handpicked Committee to Examine Safe Supply.
One of the commentary's authors says the committee wasn't particularly interested in linked data or science.
"We were seeing a lot of concerns framed around safety, but within the committee's work, they relied on experts that are not experts on safer supply," Patty Wilson said. "Many of the experts that this government went out and chose had publicly denounced safer supply before coming to the committee."
"They leaned more into ideology."
That accusation — that committee members had predetermined outcomes — has been in the public domain for some time.
When the initial committee report was released, multiple doctors and health experts from across the country voiced their displeasure.
Elsewhere in the report, the authors show how many clinicians were framed by the committee's work.
"Prescribers of safer supply, usually physicians, were depicted as causing harm, both unintentionally and intentionally," the report reads.
"Both historical and current prescribing practices were framed as harmful and a reckless approach to care," and "reckless prescribing was frequently attributed to either the influence of pharmaceutical companies or clinicians adopting a defeatist approach in their practice."
Alberta's response
Alberta's Minister of Mental Health and Addictions Dan Williams calls the commentary "an opinion piece."
Williams has long insisted safe supply — or "unsafe supply," as he refers to it — doesn't work.
"We came to that conclusion through the evidence in a thoughtful policy process, through a committee at the legislature and then built our policy," he told CTV News. "Unsafe supply isn't the silver bullet and government-funded heroin is going to make the addiction crisis worse and not better."
Williams denied that the committee was biased from the beginning, instead stating that its members were taking into conversation not only research, but "what Albertans wanted."
"I have to look at what's best for Alberta, and it's categorical that unsafe supply will damage Albertan lives," he said. "It will make our communities less safe and facilitate more addiction. We've seen this movie before."
Safe supply
Multiple data sources from other provinces show safe supply decreases both deaths and hospitalizations, "but only when it's easily accessible," said Wilson.
She believes the recovery model is also effective, but long waitlists for treatment can oftentimes cause problems.
"(We can't) frame recovery or treatment in opposition to Harm Reduction interventions," Wilson said. "We need all of them. And that's what people deserve, is all of them."
Registered Nurse and University of Calgary professor Dr. Jennifer Jackson agrees.
"What we have done is narrowed all the range of options essentially to one pathway, and that pathway isn't up and running yet," Jackson said, referring to Recovery Alberta treatment sites that are still under construction. "So we've left a lot of people stranded who are trying to access services."
"There could be overdose prevention sites, family doctors prescribing medication that can help manage addiction, nurse practitioners running clinics, there could be more phone-based and virtual services and community drop-in centres that offer supports for people with addictions."
The number of opioid-related overdose deaths in Alberta is trending in the right direction after the heights of the pandemic, but remain high.
431 deaths were reported between January and May of this year, down from 788 over the same period last year.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
opinion Tom Mulcair: Prime Minister Justin Trudeau's train wreck of a final act
In his latest column for CTVNews.ca, former NDP leader and political analyst Tom Mulcair puts a spotlight on the 'spectacular failure' of Prime Minister Justin Trudeau's final act on the political stage.
B.C. mayor gets calls from across Canada about 'crazy' plan to recruit doctors
A British Columbia community's "out-of-the-box" plan to ease its family doctor shortage by hiring physicians as city employees is sparking interest from across Canada, says Colwood Mayor Doug Kobayashi.
'There’s no support': Domestic abuse survivor shares difficulties leaving her relationship
An Edmonton woman who tried to flee an abusive relationship ended up back where she started in part due to a lack of shelter space.
opinion King Charles' Christmas: Who's in and who's out this year?
Christmas 2024 is set to be a Christmas like no other for the Royal Family, says royal commentator Afua Hagan. King Charles III has initiated the most important and significant transformation of royal Christmas celebrations in decades.
Baseball Hall of Famer Rickey Henderson dead at 65, reports say
Rickey Henderson, a Baseball Hall of Famer and Major League Baseball’s all-time stolen bases leader, is dead at 65, according to multiple reports.
Arizona third-grader saves choking friend
An Arizona third-grader is being recognized by his local fire department after saving a friend from choking.
Germans mourn the 5 killed and 200 injured in the apparent attack on a Christmas market
Germans on Saturday mourned the victims of an apparent attack in which authorities say a doctor drove into a busy outdoor Christmas market, killing five people, injuring 200 others and shaking the public’s sense of security at what would otherwise be a time of joy.
Blake Lively accuses 'It Ends With Us' director Justin Baldoni of harassment and smear campaign
Blake Lively has accused her 'It Ends With Us' director and co-star Justin Baldoni of sexual harassment on the set of the movie and a subsequent effort to “destroy' her reputation in a legal complaint.
Oysters distributed in B.C., Alberta, Ontario recalled for norovirus contamination
The Canadian Food Inspection Agency has issued a recall due to possible norovirus contamination of certain oysters distributed in British Columbia, Alberta and Ontario.