Calgary man convicted of killing 3-year-old girl wants second opinion on mental state
A sentencing hearing for a Calgary man convicted of second-degree murder in the beating death of his girlfriend's three-year-old daughter has been delayed because he wants a second opinion on his mental health.
In March, Justin Paul Bennett was found guilty of second-degree murder in the death of Ivy Wick, the daughter of Helen Wordsworth.
Ivy suffered blunt force trauma injuries on Sept. 27, 2017. She never regained consciousness and died in hospital eight days later.
Bennett had initially told the 911 operator and police that Ivy hit her head after she tripped and fell. He was arrested a year later in connection to the little girl’s death after an undercover police sting.
The 'Mr. Big' operation generated key evidence submitted by the crown. Bennett admitted he beat Ivy after she interrupted his video game.
Undercover officers befriended him as part of a fictitious criminal organization. They told Bennett they could clear his name because they had access to a corrupt medical examiner who could make a fake report. But he had to be truthful about what happened to Ivy.
Bennett said he smashed Ivy in the head, threw her against the wall and tripped her while her mother was in the shower. A videotaped conversation between Bennett and undercover officers was submitted as evidence at trial.
On Wednesday, the matter was put over to Oct. 8, at which time a date is to be set to question the original doctor about his diagnosis.
Bennett's lawyer told the court that his client complained that Dr. Reilly Smith, the psychiatrist who did his assessment, didn't like Bennett and showed bias in his report.
"He detected a real sense of animosity towards him ... and Dr. Smith's perceived animosity became even more pronounced on numerous occasions when Dr. Smith asked my client to discuss the allegations and circumstances surrounding the death of Ivy Wick," said Alan Fay.
"He tells me further that very early in the process that Dr. Smith conveyed to him that the ultimate assessment would be a negative one and he would likely be found a significant danger."
Fay asked Court of Queen's Bench Justice Blair Nixon to order a second assessment because his client couldn't afford to pay for an independent report on his own.
Crown prosecutor Tom Spark told court he would consent to the delay and agreed to have Smith attend court to be questioned on the matter but opposed another psychiatric examination.
"It's a slippery slope to start ordering second opinions to the hospital every time an offender is displeased with a report and would only contribute further to overwhelming and stretching an already thin system," Spark said.
Fay told reporters outside court that he's familiar with the doctor and has always found him to be fair and competent, but noted he was following his client's instructions.
"I haven't seen this in over 32 years in these courts. I've certainly never done it myself," he said.
But Fay said the psychiatric evaluation could have a major impact during sentencing.
"The issue at sentencing is the period of parole ineligibility. The impact of the psychiatric report frequently does impact on that particular aspect of sentencing."A second-degree murder conviction carries a life sentence with no chance of parole between 10 and 25 years.
A second-degree murder conviction carries a life sentence with no chance of parole between 10 and 25 years.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
opinion Tom Mulcair: Prime Minister Justin Trudeau's train wreck of a final act
In his latest column for CTVNews.ca, former NDP leader and political analyst Tom Mulcair puts a spotlight on the 'spectacular failure' of Prime Minister Justin Trudeau's final act on the political stage.
B.C. mayor gets calls from across Canada about 'crazy' plan to recruit doctors
A British Columbia community's "out-of-the-box" plan to ease its family doctor shortage by hiring physicians as city employees is sparking interest from across Canada, says Colwood Mayor Doug Kobayashi.
'There’s no support': Domestic abuse survivor shares difficulties leaving her relationship
An Edmonton woman who tried to flee an abusive relationship ended up back where she started in part due to a lack of shelter space.
opinion King Charles' Christmas: Who's in and who's out this year?
Christmas 2024 is set to be a Christmas like no other for the Royal Family, says royal commentator Afua Hagan. King Charles III has initiated the most important and significant transformation of royal Christmas celebrations in decades.
Baseball Hall of Famer Rickey Henderson dead at 65, reports say
Rickey Henderson, a Baseball Hall of Famer and Major League Baseball’s all-time stolen bases leader, is dead at 65, according to multiple reports.
Arizona third-grader saves choking friend
An Arizona third-grader is being recognized by his local fire department after saving a friend from choking.
Germans mourn the 5 killed and 200 injured in the apparent attack on a Christmas market
Germans on Saturday mourned the victims of an apparent attack in which authorities say a doctor drove into a busy outdoor Christmas market, killing five people, injuring 200 others and shaking the public’s sense of security at what would otherwise be a time of joy.
Blake Lively accuses 'It Ends With Us' director Justin Baldoni of harassment and smear campaign
Blake Lively has accused her 'It Ends With Us' director and co-star Justin Baldoni of sexual harassment on the set of the movie and a subsequent effort to “destroy' her reputation in a legal complaint.
Oysters distributed in B.C., Alberta, Ontario recalled for norovirus contamination
The Canadian Food Inspection Agency has issued a recall due to possible norovirus contamination of certain oysters distributed in British Columbia, Alberta and Ontario.