Study from U of C suggests 'unscientific claims' are being made by baby formula producers

An international study, which includes support from the University of Calgary, suggests baby formula companies are "highly likely" to make unscientific claims about their products.
The research, published in the British Medical Journal on Wednesday, looked at the lack of scientific evidence to back up the claims made on the labels of baby formula products.
The Canadian segment of the research was conducted by Dr. Meredith Brockway, internationally-certified lactation consultant and assistant professor with the University of Calgary's Faculty of Nursing.
Brockway says while formula provides "adequate" nutrition for babies, it lacks numerous other components that are present in human milk that positively impact infant growth and development.
"We challenge the unscientific claims that formula companies are making regarding their additives," she said in a release.
"In the 757 infant formula products identified, 608 linked to an average of two claims (ranging from one in Australia to four in the U.S.) and 31 types of claims across all products."
Of those claims, Brockway says scientific evidence was absent in 74 per cent of them.
When companies did provide data, more than half cited clinical trials, but just 14 per cent of those were registered and 90 per cent "contained a high risk of bias."
"This means that the evidence used to support these claims is really of quite low quality," Brockway said.
Brockway is advising parents to be aware when an infant formula product states it has additives to improve certain aspects of infant health, saying it's "highly likely" this is not supported by high quality scientific evidence and not worth the added cost.
She adds the claims can also overstate the perceived benefits of formula over breastfeeding and possibly undermine the practice among Canadian mothers.
In this July 19, 2011, file photo, Similac baby formula is displayed on the shelves at Shaker's IGA in Olmsted Falls, Ohio. (AP Photo/Mark Duncan)
While the research is based on observational findings and is limited, Brockway says any claims made on baby formula labels can be considered "controversial."
"We are hoping our results – which support revised regulatory frameworks for breast milk substitutes to better protect consumers – will generate lots of important discussion about the continued unethical marketing by formula companies."
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
Han Dong resigns from Liberal caucus amid foreign interference allegations
Han Dong has announced he will be sitting as an independent MP after being the subject of foreign interference allegations.

Former prime minister Stephen Harper says Canada needs a 'Conservative renaissance'
Canada needs a 'Conservative renaissance,' former prime minister Stephen Harper said Wednesday, but he cautioned that Pierre Poilievre should wait until an election before telling Canadians how he might run the country.
Biden is coming to Canada: Here's what we know about his visit
U.S. President Joe Biden is coming to Canada Thursday evening, kicking off his short but long-awaited overnight official visit to Canada. Here's what CTV News has confirmed about what will be on the agenda, and what key players are saying about the upcoming visit.
Canada's relationship with the U.S. needed rebuilding post-Trump says Ambassador Hillman
Canada's Ambassador to the U.S. Kirsten Hillman says the country’s relationship with its American counterparts required rebuilding after the Trump administration.
WeightWatchers appears set to close dozens of Canadian locations Sunday
WW International appears set to close dozens of its roughly 118 WeightWatchers locations across Canada on March 26 in what may be part of a restructuring strategy.
Police find 2 more bodies at site of Old Montreal fire; first victim identified
The death toll from last week's massive fire in Old Montreal has risen to four, Montreal police confirmed. Julien Levesque, a police spokesperson, said Wednesday evening that two more bodies were retrieved from the historic building that went up in flames last Thursday.
Top 4 quirky consumer complaints received in 2022: BBB
The Better Business Bureau (BBB) says it receives tens of thousands of complaints from consumers across Canada each year, but once in a while a "quirky" one will take them by surprise.
What are the predictions for Canada's real estate market this spring?
The Canadian real estate market has been sluggish since last year, when prospective buyers started putting off plans to purchase homes as the Bank of Canada aggressively hiked interest rates eight consecutive times. But realtors see many edging toward a purchase once more.
More than half of Canadians OK with telling lies to spare others’ feelings: Poll
According to a new poll conducted by Research Co., more than half of Canadians surveyed said it is permissible to lie to spare someone’s feelings.