Study from U of C suggests 'unscientific claims' are being made by baby formula producers
![Little science behind baby formula benefits An international study, which included research conducted at the University of Calgary, found many of the claims on labels of baby formula have little, if any, scientific evidence to support them. (AP Photo/David J. Phillip)](/content/dam/ctvnews/en/images/2023/2/16/little-science-behind-baby-formula-benefits-1-6276785-1676569004283.jpg)
An international study, which includes support from the University of Calgary, suggests baby formula companies are "highly likely" to make unscientific claims about their products.
The research, published in the British Medical Journal on Wednesday, looked at the lack of scientific evidence to back up the claims made on the labels of baby formula products.
The Canadian segment of the research was conducted by Dr. Meredith Brockway, internationally-certified lactation consultant and assistant professor with the University of Calgary's Faculty of Nursing.
Brockway says while formula provides "adequate" nutrition for babies, it lacks numerous other components that are present in human milk that positively impact infant growth and development.
"We challenge the unscientific claims that formula companies are making regarding their additives," she said in a release.
"In the 757 infant formula products identified, 608 linked to an average of two claims (ranging from one in Australia to four in the U.S.) and 31 types of claims across all products."
Of those claims, Brockway says scientific evidence was absent in 74 per cent of them.
When companies did provide data, more than half cited clinical trials, but just 14 per cent of those were registered and 90 per cent "contained a high risk of bias."
"This means that the evidence used to support these claims is really of quite low quality," Brockway said.
Brockway is advising parents to be aware when an infant formula product states it has additives to improve certain aspects of infant health, saying it's "highly likely" this is not supported by high quality scientific evidence and not worth the added cost.
She adds the claims can also overstate the perceived benefits of formula over breastfeeding and possibly undermine the practice among Canadian mothers.
In this July 19, 2011, file photo, Similac baby formula is displayed on the shelves at Shaker's IGA in Olmsted Falls, Ohio. (AP Photo/Mark Duncan)
While the research is based on observational findings and is limited, Brockway says any claims made on baby formula labels can be considered "controversial."
"We are hoping our results – which support revised regulatory frameworks for breast milk substitutes to better protect consumers – will generate lots of important discussion about the continued unethical marketing by formula companies."
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
![](https://www.ctvnews.ca/polopoly_fs/1.6949582.1720016002!/httpImage/image.png_gen/derivatives/landscape_800/image.png)
DEVELOPING Canada issues travel warning as Hurricane Beryl tears through region
As Hurricane Beryl rips toward the southeast Caribbean, Global Affairs Canada is warning travellers to avoid non-essential travel to Jamaica as well as several countries in the region.
Delta flight diverts to New York after passengers are served spoiled food
A Delta flight from Detroit to Amsterdam was diverted to New York's Kennedy Airport on Wednesday after passengers were served spoiled food, airline officials said.
Ontario man suffers cardiac arrest in Florida. This is why insurance won't cover his $620,000 hospital bill
An Ontario man who wanted to spend time with his family in Florida was hospitalized after suffering a cardiac arrest at the airport as he was about to fly back to Canada.
Tracking Hurricane Beryl: Deadly storm roars toward Jamaica
Hurricane Beryl was roaring toward Jamaica on Wednesday, with islanders scrambling to make preparations after the powerful Category 4 storm earlier killed at least six people and caused significant damage in the southeast Caribbean.
Video shows the scale of Hurricane Beryl as seen from space
Video captured from the International Space Station earlier this week shows the size of Hurricane Beryl as it churned over the Caribbean.
opinion Are financial advisors just glorified salespeople?
Financial advisors can be an excellent resource for busy consumers, but recent allegations against employees of major Canadian banks have raised questions about the integrity of financial advice. Personal finance contributor Christopher Liew addresses some of these concerns and highlights the distinction between unethical practices and the genuine value that good advisors can offer.
Thousands of heat pumps recalled over risk of 'excessive heat exposure'
Health Canada is recalling thousands of popular heat pumps across the country due to a potential risk of 'excessive heat exposure.'
RCMP searching for B.C. arson suspect whose pants caught on fire
Authorities are asking for the public's help identifying a suspect whose pants caught fire after an alleged arson in B.C.'s Lower Mainland earlier this year.
As hurricane approaches, London, Ont., newlyweds stranded in Jamaica due to WestJet strike
Newlyweds from London, Ont., are trapped in Jamaica, as Category 5 Hurricane Beryl approaches.