Accused in fatal Calgary hit-and-run found not guilty
Crown prosecutors couldn't prove a Calgary man was the driver of a vehicle involved in the hit-and-run death of 27-year-old Alek Athiebiok (Aloka) Akot in 2022.
On Oct. 21, Justice J.D. Sawa of the Alberta Court of Justice acquitted Hani Salama, the registered owner of the black Mercedes Benz that the court heard was the vehicle that ran down the mother while she was in a marked crosswalk in Forest Lawn.
In his reasons, released on Nov. 25, Sawa said prosecutors did not prove beyond a reasonable doubt that Salama was behind the wheel at the time of the crash.
- Sign up for breaking news alerts from CTV News, right at your fingertips
- The information you need to know, sent directly to you: Download the CTV News App
At about 7:55 p.m. on Oct. 27, 2022, Akot was struck by a vehicle while crossing at the intersection of 17 Avenue and 44 Street S.E.
The driver of the vehicle did not remain at the scene.
In the ruling, the court said the Crown based its case on several pieces of evidence, including video footage of the hit-and-run, cellphone records and an examination of the vehicle itself, which was seized by police four days later.
Footage of the hit-and-run was captured by two cameras: one positioned at a bus rapid transit lane and the other at a nearby dental office. The Crown said each camera gave a clear view of the hit-and-run and the black Mercedes driving away from the scene.
Prosecutors also submitted cellphone evidence from a device registered to a person with a similar name as the accused, which a Crown witness said linked Salama to the crime.
"Her analysis showed that the last communication associated to the cellphone on Oct. 27, 2022, prior to the accident was at approximately 6:55 p.m., about an hour before," Sawa said.
"The next communication following the accident on that date was at 8:09 p.m. approximately 14 minutes after. The communication at 6:55 p.m. was in the vicinity of the accident but it was one hour before the accident with no activity on the cellphone again until 8:09 p.m."
The address on the cellphone was linked to an apartment in northwest Calgary, which was where the Mercedes was recovered from.
Salama did not testify in court and his defence counsel provided no evidence.
Undated photograph of Aloka Akot and her mother Nybol Acor. Akot was killed in an Oct. 27 hit-and-run on 17th Avenue S.E. (supplied: family of Aloka Akot)
Circumstantial evidence, judge says
In his reasons, Sawa said while the evidence presented by the Crown proved Salama was the registered owner of the Mercedes and the vehicle was involved in the hit-and-run, it did not prove that Salama was the driver.
"His DNA was obtained from the steering wheel of the Mercedes after it was seized by police. There is no doubt that the Mercedes was in the accident which caused the death of Ms. Akot.
"There is no direct evidence of identity and no eyewitnesses who could identify the driver."
Sawa said while the video clips submitted by the Crown were of "good quality" and gave clear views of the incident, neither one accurately identified the driver of the Mercedes.
While the phone records did lead police to locate the vehicle that was positively identified as the one involved in the hit-and-run, Sawa said there was no evidence Salama was residing at the apartment.
The Crown also failed to prove that the iPhone 6, analyzed by police, belonged to the accused, Sawa said.
"This was an obvious gap in the evidence in terms of linking Hani Salama to the records," he wrote.
In the analysis of the Mercedes, police found DNA of the accused on the steering wheel.
Sawa said this fact doesn't necessarily mean he was the driver, only "that he was in contact with the steering wheel sometime prior to the date of the seizure."
"It must be noted there is a four-day gap between the date of the accident and the date of the seizure and the DNA evidence must be evaluated with reference to the totality of the evidence," Sawa wrote.
Undated image of Aloka Akot, the 27-year-old Calgary woman killed in an Oct. 27 hit-and-run on 17th Avenue S.E. (supplied: family of Aloka Akot)
There was also some doubt about the ownership of the Mercedes at the time it was seized, Sawa said.
On Oct. 31, 2022, the day it was located by police, Salama transferred registration of the vehicle to his father.
While that action may be perceived to "evade detection for the accident," Sawa said more proof was needed.
"The relevance of any piece of after-the-fact conduct is a fact-driven exercise and depends on the particular facts of the case."
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
Upcoming GST relief causes confusion for some small Canadian businesses
A tax break for the holiday season will start this week, giving some Canadians relief on year-end shopping. But for small businesses, confusion around what applies for the GST relief has emerged.
Public support key but harder to keep as Canada Post strike drags on, experts say
Public support is key to the success of a strike, experts say, but as the Canada Post strike drags on, that support is likely getting harder to maintain.
Ontario mulls U.S. booze ban as Trump brushes off Ford's threat to cut electricity
Incoming U.S. president Donald Trump is brushing off Ontario's threat to restrict electricity exports in retaliation for sweeping tariffs on Canadian goods, as the province floats the idea of effectively barring sales of American alcohol.
Suspected Chinese spy with business ties to Prince Andrew barred from U.K.
A suspected Chinese spy with business ties to Prince Andrew has been barred from the U.K. because of concerns he poses a threat to national security.
Russia targets Ukrainian infrastructure with a massive attack by cruise missiles and drones
Russia launched a massive aerial attack against Ukraine on Friday, firing 93 cruise and ballistic missiles and almost 200 drones, Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy said, describing it as one of the heaviest bombardments of the country's energy sector since Russia's full-scale invasion almost three years ago.
Canadian officials eyed 'new opportunities' no matter who won U.S. election: memos
As the U.S. presidential election loomed, Canadian officials envisioned new opportunities for co-operation with their southern neighbour on nuclear energy, supply chain security and carbon capture technologies — no matter who won the contest, newly released government memos show.
Man who set fires inside Calgary's municipal building lost testicle during arrest: ASIRT
Two Calgary police officers have been cleared of any wrongdoing in an incident that saw a suspect lose a testicle after being shot with an anti-riot weapon.
She took a DNA test for fun. Police used it to charge her grandmother with murder in a cold case
According to court documents, detectives reopened the cold case in 2017 and then worked with a forensics company to extract DNA from Baby Garnet's partial femur, before sending the results to Identifinders International.
President Macron names centrist ally Bayrou as France's next prime minister
French President Emmanuel Macron on Friday named centrist ally Francois Bayrou as prime minister, after a historic parliamentary vote ousted the previous government last week.