Alberta judge mulls options after ex-justice minister threatens defamation in trial
A judge who is to rule on a defamation threat sent in the middle of a civil trial by Alberta's former justice minister has been told the warning reignited fear and anxiety in the plaintiff and led another witness to beg off testifying.
“It's not going to be easy to put the toothpaste back in the tube,” lawyer Allan Garber told Court of Queen's Bench Justice Doreen Sulyma on Monday.
“A mistrial would not be in anyone's best interests, but I do want to say this has been difficult.”
Sulyma is to deliver a ruling in the matter Wednesday morning. There are various possible outcomes, including a finding of contempt.
Garber represents Dr. Anny Sauvageau, Alberta's former chief medical examiner. Sauvageau is suing the province for $7.6 million in lost wages and benefits after her contract was not renewed in 2014.
Jonathan Denis was Alberta's justice minister at the time.
Sauvageau had been testifying before Sulyma over the past few days in the civil trial.
The process slammed to a halt Friday after it was revealed a representative for Denis had sent a letter threatening to sue her for defamation tied to comments she was making on the witness stand.
However, those testifying in court have full immunity from defamation in order to compel the whole, unvarnished truth.
Sauvageau, in an affidavit, said she has never defamed Denis.
Garber told court the letter doesn't detail the alleged defamation and “should be interpreted as a threat to the plaintiff and an attempt to intimidate the plaintiff to protect the reputation of Mr. Denis.”
He added that after news of Friday's letter was published in the media, a potential witness said he no longer wished to testify.
Brendan Miller, a lawyer for Denis, told the judge that the letter was not well drafted and was poorly timed, coming in the middle of the court case.
But Miller stressed the letter was misinterpreted.
He agreed it's a well-understood legal principle that testimony in court cases can't be used for defamation lawsuits.
But he noted such testimony can be used to help identify and corroborate similar statements made outside court. And that, said Miller, was what the letter was doing: cautioning Sauvageau over comments she may be making to media outside court.
“There should be no fear whatsoever for the doctor to testify,” said Miller.
Garber told court he had no idea what Miller was talking about.
“There's no reference anywhere (in the letter) to (Sauvageau) having said anything to the media - and she's never done that,” he said.
Miller said Denis, who was present in court Monday, was sorry for problems the letter had caused. Sauvageau was also in court, on the opposite side of the public gallery from Denis.
The letter was written by lawyer Kyle Shewchuk on behalf of Denis. As the proceedings closed Monday, Shewchuk stood and apologized to Sulyma.
“This has been a learning experience for me, as I'm a new lawyer to the bar,” said Shewchuk.
The trial revolves around Sauvageau's performance as chief medical examiner, a job she held from 2011 to the end of 2014.
Sauvageau alleges she was forced out of the job as punishment after raising concerns, including political interference in cases and billing on body pickups.
The government, in turn, says Sauvageau's contract was not renewed because she was seeking to exercise authority beyond the scope of her job while displaying questionable judgment and decision making.
Claims from either side have yet to be proven in court.
Sauvageau said in her affidavit that the letter from Denis's lawyer has had a chilling effect because she does not have a job and fears the “financial consequences” of fighting a defamation lawsuit.
“I am now fearful to give my evidence in this trial,” wrote Sauvageau.
This report by The Canadian Press was first published April 11, 2022
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
Ontario gave parents more than $1B in cash over 2 years. Here's where the money went
During the pandemic, the Ontario government started to hand out cash to parents to help offset the cost of at-home learning while schools were shuttered.
One dead, 26 wounded in overnight shooting in Ohio: reports
A shooting on a street in Akron, Ohio, killed one man and wounded 26 other people early Sunday morning, according to reports by local news outlets.
Do this once a month and extend your life by up to 10 years. No gym required
Research shows that art experiences, whether as a maker or a beholder, transform our biology by rewiring our brains and triggering the release of neurochemicals, hormones and endorphins.
Ambassador says interactions with Russia 'quite limited' but 'not unfriendly'
Canada's ambassador to Russia says while Ottawa has 'grave concerns' about the Kremlin's 'longer-term trends,' the war in Ukraine is 'a primary barrier to a change in the relationship.'
Bathroom break nearly derails $22 million project at city council meeting
A brief break during Wednesday's city council meeting in Saskatoon nearly cost the city dearly.
Mass parachute jump over Normandy kicks off commemorations for the 80th anniversary of D-Day
Parachutists jumping from Second World War-era planes hurled themselves Sunday into now peaceful Normandy skies where war once raged, heralding a week of ceremonies for the fast-disappearing generation of Allied troops who fought from D-Day beaches 80 years ago.
Lanny McDonald and a few old Flames take the Stanley Cup on a surprise visit to the man who saved his life
The Stanley Cup was passing through town Friday, and Lanny Legend took it upon himself to take it for a surprise visit.
South Korea vows 'unbearable' retaliation against North Korea over its launch of trash balloons
South Korea said Sunday it’ll soon take retaliatory steps against North Korea over its launch of trash-carrying balloons across the border and other provocations.
Chad Daybell sentenced to death for killing wife and girlfriend’s two children in jury decision
Jurors resumed deliberations Saturday on whether a man should be sentenced to death after being convicted days earlier of the murders of his wife and his girlfriend’s two youngest children in Idaho.