Some Conservatives disagree with MP calling Trudeau a dictator in House of Commons
Lethbridge member of Parliament Rachael Thomas told the House of Commons the Oxford dictionary definition of the word dictator this week, saying "many Canadians" feel it applies to Prime Minister Justin Trudeau.
“A ruler with total power over a country, especially one who has gained it using force,” said Thomas.
Her office doubled down Wednesday, saying she did not call Trudeau a dictator.
“Taking part of a response out of context makes for an interesting story, but it does not make for an accurate one,” said her policy advisor, Sarah Fischer.
Thomas' office would not say what data she used to suggest "many Canadians" feel this way.
Moments before the statement on Monday, Saskatoon-Ouest MP Brad Redekopp blasted Trudeau’s use of the Emergencies Act.
“To call in police forces to crush peaceful protesters, under the jackboot of the prime minister’s basic dictatorship,” said Redekopp.
“Another dictator is currently using his war machine to crush our friends in Ukraine.”
Calgary-Nosehill Conservative MP Michelle Rempel-Garner, who is a colleague of Thomas and Redekopp, says elected officials need to choose their words carefully.
“I think it's also incumbent upon all legislators to be precise in their language,” said Rempel-Garner.
“There are many people in Canada that have fled countries, Venezuela comes to mind, where you have a dictator like (Nicolas) Maduro at the helm. I just think its incumbent for legislators to inspire Canadians to ensure that our democracy is healthy, our democratic institutions are healthy.”
She adds that the prime minister’s language toward those who are vaccine hesitant or against public health restrictions has brought with it a distaste for Canadian politics.
“The prime minister has a responsibility to show Canadians that our democratic institutions are healthy and certainly the abuse of the Emergencies Act, putting it mildly, not helpful in that regard,” said Rempel-Garner.
Alberta Premier Jason Kenney, who served several years in Ottawa as an MP, says his majority government under former prime minister Stephen Harper was also targeted by opposition MPs, being called an "elected dictatorship."
But Kenney added Trudeau does not fit the definition.
“I disagree with Justin Trudeau on the vast majority of issues. I think he's been too quick to use extraordinary powers like the Emergencies Act,” Kenney told reporters.
“But for all of that, I think it's unhelpful and corrosive to suggest that that he operates like, let's say, the president of China or the president of Russia.”
One University of Lethbridge political scientist says Thomas is only inflaming political discourse in Canada.
“If she was taking a course with me, I would have to give her an F for the course,” said Trevor Harrison.
“If you don't like something, you just simply stick a label on it. We've kind of lost the capacity to have an intelligent debate.”
Trudeau was chastised by a handful of MEPs last week in European Parliament, where he gave a speech, referring to him as a dictator trampling on the rights of those who don't agree with him.
The prime minister’s office did not respond to a request for comment, referring CTV to comments by MP Mark Gerretsen, who is also Parliamentary secretary to the leader of the government in the House of Commons.
“Not only is that an incredible disservice to the people of Canada, but think of what it means to the people of Ukraine, to somehow suggest that the prime minister of this country is a dictator, and to compare him to (Russian President Vladimir) Putin and the incredibly audacious things he is doing to the people of Ukraine,” said Gerretsen.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
Donald Trump says he urged Wayne Gretzky to run for prime minister in Christmas visit
U.S. president-elect Donald Trump says he told Canadian hockey legend Wayne Gretzky he should run for prime minister during a Christmas visit but adds that the athlete declined interest in politics.
Historical mysteries solved by science in 2024
This year, scientists were able to pull back the curtain on mysteries surrounding figures across history, both known and unknown, to reveal more about their unique stories.
King Charles III focuses Christmas message on healthcare workers in year marked by royal illnesses
King Charles III used his annual Christmas message Wednesday to hail the selflessness of those who have cared for him and the Princess of Wales this year, after both were diagnosed with cancer.
Mother-daughter duo pursuing university dreams at the same time
For one University of Windsor student, what is typically a chance to gain independence from her parents has become a chance to spend more time with her biggest cheerleader — her mom.
Thousands without power on Christmas as winds, rain continue in B.C. coastal areas
Thousands of people in British Columbia are without power on Christmas Day as ongoing rainfall and strong winds collapse power lines, disrupt travel and toss around holiday decorations.
Ho! Ho! HOLY that's cold! Montreal boogie boarder in Santa suit hits St. Lawrence waters
Montreal body surfer Carlos Hebert-Plante boogie boards all year round, and donned a Santa Claus suit to hit the water on Christmas Day in -14 degree Celsius weather.
Canadian activist accuses Hong Kong of meddling, but is proud of reward for arrest
A Vancouver-based activist is accusing Hong Kong authorities of meddling in Canada’s internal affairs after police in the Chinese territory issued a warrant for his arrest.
New York taxi driver hits 6 pedestrians, 3 taken to hospital, police say
A taxicab hit six pedestrians in midtown Manhattan on Wednesday, police said, with three people — including a 9-year-old boy — transported to hospitals for their injuries.
Azerbaijani airliner crashes in Kazakhstan, killing 38 with 29 survivors, officials say
An Azerbaijani airliner with 67 people onboard crashed Wednesday near the Kazakhstani city of Aktau, killing 38 people and leaving 29 survivors, a Kazakh official said.