Lawyer for Coutts protester suggests jury rushed to judgment before long weekend
The lawyer for a man convicted of mischief for his actions at the Coutts border blockade drew the ire of a judge Monday by suggesting jurors rushed to a verdict because they were in a hurry to get out before the August long weekend.
Marilyn Burns also drew criticism from the Crown prosecutor when she hinted the jurors were culturally biased when they convicted Anthony Olienick on a firearms possession charge.
Burns’ comments came in Court of King's Bench as lawyers on both sides and Justice David Labrenz began discussing what facts should be considered in determining a fit sentence for Olienick and Chris Carbert.
Earlier this month, a jury convicted Olienick and Carbert of mischief and possession of a firearm for a dangerous purpose for their role at the Coutts border blockade in early 2022.
Olienick was also convicted of possession of a pipe bomb.
The jury found both not guilty of the more serious charge of conspiring to murder police officers.
The jury came to a decision late on the night of Friday, Aug. 2, before the August long weekend on its third day of deliberations.
Burns told Labrenz the timing was curious.
"This jury took a long time to come to this decision,” said Burns. “Did they come to the same conclusion on count two for different reasons because it was late on a Friday evening before a long weekend and there were compromises? We can't know that."
Labrenz shot back: “You're being very insulting to the jury. (Are you) trying to insinuate they rushed to judgment because it was a long weekend?"
Burns replied, “They were a great jury. I don’t mean to be insulting."
Burns also drew criticism when, while discussing the weapons charge, she said the jury made a “cultural decision.”
She did not explain the remark, but Crown prosecutor Steven Johnston told court she was inferring an urban bias.
“The jury is who we got,” Johnston told court.
“(Burns) making that suggestion that they're just somehow just city folk that didn't understand how the rural folk use firearms is just beyond the pale, quite frankly.”
Details of what is discussed inside the jury room are private.
A judge normally makes his findings of facts used in sentencing based on his or her own decision but after a jury trial will hear arguments from both the Crown and defence on their interpretations.
Olienick and Carbert were charged after RCMP found guns, ammunition and body armour in trailers near the blockade at the key Canada-U.S. border crossing. The blockade was one of several held across the country to protest COVID-19 rules and vaccine mandates.
Carbert's lawyer, Katherin Beyak, played down her client’s weapon-possession conviction as simple pride in a new weapon.
"I would urge this court to find that Mr. Carbert's dangerous purpose was potentially just showing off," Beyak said. "There's no violence being directed by Mr. Carbert toward the police.”
Labrenz challenged that remark. He noted that there were text messages from Carbert to his mother talking about a war coming and that he may not survive it.
"There's no immediacy to that threat," Beyak said.
"Sounds pretty immediate to me," Labrenz said.
"Not that the war's about to start," she replied.
Johnston said the not-guilty verdict on the conspiracy charge opened the door for the jurors to find the pair not guilty on the weapons count.
But they didn’t, said Johnston, adding that fact alone is noteworthy in sentencing. He said the jury believed the guns were there to be used against police if necessary, hence the conviction on that count.
He noted that Olienick told officers that he considered himself a "sheepdog" who would be there to protect the protesters if police advanced on them.
"The sheepdog defence is another way of looking to say they're there -- that being the firearms and ammunition and all the armoury -- to have a shootout with police. That's what the jury has found in the Crown's position," Johnston said.
--
This report by The Canadian Press was first published on Aug. 26, 2024.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
Chances of disruption increasing as Air Canada pilot talks near deadline
Air Canada says some operations will start to be affected today as time is running out before a potential shutdown because of a labour dispute with its pilots
Canadian health regulators ban this common food additive. Here's what you need to know
In a move to safeguard public heath, Health Canada has officially banned the use of brominated vegetable oil (BVO) as a food additive. Here's what you need to know.
Criminal trial for 'Freedom Convoy' organizers Lich and Barber to end after one year
Today is expected to mark the end of the criminal trial for two prominent organizers of the 'Freedom Convoy' protest, more than one year after the proceedings began.
Passenger ordered to pay more than US$5,000 in fuel costs after flight diverted due to bad behaviour
A problematic airline passenger has been hit with an unusual form of punishment – he has to pay back the airline for the cost of fuel.
Landlord tried to convert 1-bedroom units into multiple rooms, Metro Vancouver tenants say
It was the loud construction and series of Amazon packages that tipped off a group of tenants living at a rental building in New Westminster, B.C.
Canadian woman dies after being caught in a sudden snowstorm in Italy's Dolomite mountains
A 56-year-old Canadian woman died after being caught in a sudden snowstorm in Italy’s Dolomite mountains and her companion was being treated for severe hypothermia, Italy’s Alpine Rescue Corps said Friday.
Family of Sikh man speaks out against Toronto-area hospital after beard shaved
The family of a Sikh man from Brampton is seeking an apology, an explanation, and a promise to do better from the local hospital network after they say the facial hair of their loved one was removed without their consent.
Realtor fined by B.C. regulator after property photos digitally altered
A British Columbia Realtor has been fined thousands of dollars after a property listing was found to contain photos that were digitally altered to hide peeling paint and show furnishings that did not exist.
2 dead, third in critical condition after attack in Kingston, Ont., suspect arrested
Two people are dead and a third suffered life-threatening injuries following an attack at an encampment in Kingston, Ont., Thursday. A suspect has been arrested following a multi-hour standoff.