Dog owner speaks out after court rules dogs euthanized in fatal senior death
An emotional Denis Bagaric spoke to CTV News outside of court on Thursday after a judge ruled his two remaining dogs would be killed, after a two year court battle on their fate, for the role they played in the death of a Calgary senior in June 2022.
"It's a big mess up," said Bagaric. "I wake up every morning screaming and crying."
Bagaric tried holding back tears, but was emotional as he recalled that day. He was hosting a barbeque where Williams was invited, before the dogs got out and mauled her to death.
It's been a nightmare," he said. "Before I came to Canada, life was hell, but then as you grow older, you develop love and things you care for. I love animals, it's kind of my favorite thing. I loved Betty. So it's hard. I never wanted all the dogs. I couldn't find homes for them. Nobody wanted them. So I kept them. I expected a fairy tale and here we are."
Smoki, Cinnamon and Bossi are Staffordshire terrier dogs. Smoki has since been euthanized for the role he played in the death of Betty Ann Williams June 5, 2022.
The 86-year-old suffered fatal injuries to her head, neck, face and body that led to her death after three dogs escaped a fenced and gated backyard and attacked her while she was gardening in a back alley.
Bagaric and Williams were next door neighbours.
"My dogs were never trained to harm nobody," he said.
Grievous wounds, multiple cuts
Court heard that the woman’s wounds were grievous: multiple cuts and bruises to her head and neck; the vertebrae just below her skull fractured, as was the bone under her jaw; injuries to her jugular vein branches and carotid artery; bruises on her legs and cuts on her arms.
The three dogs seized by City of Calgary animal control following a fatal June 5, 2022, attack on a senior in northwest Calgary. (Facebook/Denis Bagaric)
Bagaric says he wanted to tell his side of the story but was advised against it by lawyers.
The city applied to the court to have his two remaining dogs euthanized, which the judge agreed with on Thursday, in his decision.
"These dogs should not be returned to the community because they are a high risk and a danger to the public," Justice Bruce Fraser ruled Thursday.
"The only option is to direct them to be destroyed."
Bagaric asked that the dogs instead be adopted out and given behaviour modification.
His lawyer had argued the two should be spared because there was no proof they were involved.
Fraser disagreed."The photos demonstrate horrific injuries to Miss Williams all over her body that led to her death, particularly to her head, jaw, neck and face. Her lip and one ear had been ripped off. She was covered in blood," Fraser said.
"Miss Williams died a most horrible death."
Prohibited
Bagaric has already been fined $18,000 and prohibited from pet ownership for 15 years. He pleaded guilty earlier to two city bylaw charges: an animal attacking a person causing severe injury, and animals running at large.
The judge in that case said he was satisfied beyond a reasonable doubt that all three dogs were involved in the attack.
Bagaric says he had taken Williams to the doctor before, ran errands with her and has pictures of her and the dogs together.
His two remaining dogs have been in the custody of the city for 738 days.
"I couldn't go see my dogs, and then for people saying I don't have no remorse, man , I loved Betty like a mom, I got photos I was never even allowed to show anybody these things," he said.
Bagaric says he plans on spending $15,000 on a gold memorial for Williams that will sit near her house.
"I cry every day, I'm not a big tough guy, I do care for animals and I cared for Betty," said Bagaric. "I mean, that breaks me, breaks me in half. For my own peace, I really wish that I would have been in her place. I do, every single day. It's a horrible thing that happened."
Some conclusion: niece
Nancy Atkinson, is Williams' niece.
"It's just nice to know that there's finally some conclusion to this, and these dogs aren't going to be out there somewhere," she said from her Ontario home.
Atkinson says she is thankful this situation has finally been resolved. "To hear it's finally happened, it should have happened two years ago, right after the attack," said Atkinson.
"But he(Bagaric) wanted to fight it, and the city has been taking care of them (the dogs) for the past two years, but I'm glad the judge made the decision that they will be destroyed. To finally have a conclusion, it is nice to hopefully try to move on and remember better times, happier memories of her than what happened."
Atkinson says her aunt was a bright light, living a long fulfilling life before her death. "She was a tiny little woman, but she was still a force of nature," said Atkinson.
"She's very independent, she bought the house by herself. She did a lot of work in the house, on her own, took care of her gardens and everything. She was in the air force, and had a wicked sense of humor."
Betty Williams, the 86-year-old Calgary resident who was mauled to death June 5
Atkinson says Williams would always remember to connect with family at the times that meant the most.
"She was very thoughtful about her family, birthdays, Christmas, we'd always get cards in the mails and letters and things from her that, with the distance between us, we didn't see her very often but, she always seemed to be thinking of us," said Atkinson.
She adds that she does not believe Bagaric has any remorse and is sad that his dogs are going to be destroyed.
"I think any remorse he has is over losing his dogs," she said. "I don't feel like he really cared that much about what happened to her, and it was just sort of, 'Oh, too bad. But now my dogs are gone.'"
Bagaric was told if he did not appeal he would have a chance to say goodbye to his dogs, under the care of Animal Bylaw Services either on Thursday or Friday. There is no set date for them to be euthanized.
With files from The Canadian Press
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
Things a pediatrician would never let their child do
As summer begins for most children around Canada, CTV News spoke with a number of pediatric health professionals about the best practices for raising kids, and how the profession has evolved since the COVID-19 pandemic.
Should he stay or should he go now? A look at Trudeau's options after byelection loss
A historic defeat for the Liberals in a downtown Toronto byelection has put a glaring question mark on Prime Minister Justin Trudeau's political future. Here's a look at the options Trudeau and the Liberals face as they enter a summer of soul-searching.
Alabama man denied office after winning election reaches proposed settlement to become town's first Black mayor
An Alabama town and a Black man who was prevented from becoming its mayor after winning his 2020 election have reached a proposed settlement, according to federal court documents.
'Why did I have this surgery?' Ont. mother seeks answers after son's tonsil surgery
An Ontario mother said it looked like a horror movie when she flicked on the lights of her son’s bedroom to find him projectile vomiting blood after his tonsils were removed at McMaster Children’s Hospital.
WestJet mechanics issue strike notice for possible job action Friday
WestJet says it faces a possible strike by its mechanics starting as early as Friday.
New experience in Halifax gets people up close and personal to the ocean's most feared predator
Atlantic Shark Expeditions launched a new shark cage experience which gives brave attendees a chance to get up close and personal with the oceans most feared predator.
Many older adults are still taking daily aspirin, even though some shouldn't be, experts say
Some seniors continue to take a daily aspirin in the hopes of reducing their cardiovascular disease risk, even though the practice is only recommended for certain high-risk patients -- and taking it without a doctor's recommendation can come with significant risks.
Flatulent cows and pigs will face a carbon tax in Denmark, a world first
Denmark will tax livestock farmers for the greenhouse gases emitted by their cows, sheep and pigs from 2030, the first country in the world to do so as it targets a major source of methane emissions, one of the most potent gases contributing to global warming.
When a mole went 'rogue,' she knew something was wrong. What followed was years of cancer 'being very sneaky'
Mary Lynn LeBlanc first noticed a mole on her left shoulder about seven years ago. At first, doctors didn't find anything worrying about it. But in 2020, she noticed it looked different and grew to the size of a nickel.