Judge rules Hinshaw responses about cabinet direction and health orders should be public record
An Alberta judge has decided responses from the chief medical officer of health to questions about direction from cabinet should be made public as part of an ongoing court challenge on the constitutionality of Alberta's public health restrictions.
Lawyers for plaintiffs in the trial have argued their Charter rights were infringed by public health restrictions put in place to manage the COVID-19 pandemic.
Court documents list the plaintiffs as Baptist Churches based in Calgary and Medicine Hat, a fitness centre operator and two other individuals.
Defendants are the Province of Alberta and Chief Medical Officer of Health (CMOH) Dr. Deena Hinshaw.
The court challenge is also looking to determine if the provincial cabinet committee in charge of public health orders directed Hinshaw to impose restrictions that were more rigorous than her recommendations or targeted on specific groups of citizens.
Lawyers involved agreed to allow Justice B.E. Romaine to ask Hinshaw three questions in a private hearing.
Those questions were:
- Did the Premier and Cabinet, including the PICC and EMCC (the "Cabinet") ever direct you, Dr. Hinshaw, to impose more severe restrictions in your CMOH orders than you had recommended to them?
- Did Cabinet ever direct you to impose more severe restrictions on particular groups such as churches, gyms, schools, and small businesses than you had recommended to them?
- Did you ever recommend to Cabinet that restriction should be lifted or loosened at any period of time and that recommendation was refused or ignored by Cabinet?
Crown prosecutors tried to shield Hinshaw's responses, claiming "public interest immunity" and arguing discussions with cabinet regarding COVID-19 pandemic policy must be kept confidential.
However, in Romaine's April 26 decision, there is a countervailing public interest in disclosing Hinshaw's responses to the three questions that outweighs keeping it out of the public.
"The answers to the questions will therefore become part of the hearing record," reads the decision.
Jeffrey Rath, a lawyer for one of the plaintiffs, called it "a landmark decision."
"And I think that it's really heartening and refreshing to see that the courts are actually putting weight on the public interest to transparency with regard to decisions that have affected and destroyed so many lives in the province of Alberta," he said.
The decision will also have "very far reaching implications" for cabinet confidentiality in Canada, said Rath.
"The decisions that we're challenging are not decisions of Deena Hinshaw anymore, and that the judges seem to accept the Deena Hinshaw testimony, that all of the decisions that are being challenged, are in fact, cabinet decisions, when cabinet itself was trying to hide behind Dr. Hinshaw, and pretend that these were medical decisions," he said.
"So I think that whole chestnut can be thrown out the window."
Rath added he still has questions around whose idea it was to announce 'The Best Summer Ever' in 2021.
"Was that a Deena Hinshaw order or was that Jason Kenney for political reasons, you know, trying to have a Calgary Stampede and go out and flip pancakes in the middle of a pandemic, which may or may not have led to the Delta wave," he said.
"We need answers to these questions. The whole process to us seems like it's been very ad hoc, they're making it up as they go along."
Both Hinshaw and Health Minister Jason Copping declined to answer any questions on the judge's decision.
Read the ruling below:
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
There's actually no such thing as vegetables. Here's why you should eat them anyway
The rumours are true: Vegetables aren't real — that is, in botany, anyway. While the term fruit is recognized botanically as anything that contains a seed or seeds, vegetable is actually a broad umbrella term.
'It looked so legit': Ontario man pays $7,700 for luxury villa found on Booking.com, but the listing was fake
An Ontario man says he paid more than $7,700 for a luxury villa he found on a popular travel website -- but the listing was fake.
The Met Gala was in full bloom with Zendaya, Jennifer Lopez, Mindy Kaling among the standout stars
The Met Gala and its fashionista A-listers on Monday included Jennifer Lopez, Zendaya and a parade of others in a swirl of flora and fauna looks on a green-tinged carpet lined by live foliage.
Israeli forces seize Rafah border crossing in Gaza, putting ceasefire talks on knife's edge
Israeli tanks seized control of Gaza's vital Rafah border crossing on Tuesday as Israel brushed off urgent warnings from close allies and moved into the southern city even as cease-fire negotiations with Hamas remained on a knife's edge.
Canadian cadets rock mullets and place second at U.S. military competition
Sporting mullets, Canadian Armed Forces officer cadets placed second in an annual military skills competition in the U.S.
Noelia Voigt resigns as Miss USA, citing her mental health
Noelia Voigt, who was crowned Miss USA in November 2023, has announced she is resigning from her role, saying the decision is in the best interest of her mental health.
Putin begins his fifth term as president, more in control of Russia than ever
Vladimir Putin began his fifth term Tuesday as Russian leader at a glittering Kremlin inauguration, setting out on another six years in office after destroying his political opponents, launching a devastating war in Ukraine and concentrating all power in his hands.
Winnipeg man admits to killing four women, argues he's not criminally responsible
Defence lawyers of Jeremy Skibicki have admitted in court the accused killed four Indigenous women, but argues he is not criminally responsible for the deaths by way of mental disorder – this latest development has triggered a judge-alone trial rather than a jury trial.
Mediterranean staple may lower your risk of death from dementia, study finds
A daily spoonful of olive oil could lower your risk of dying from dementia, according to a new study by Harvard scientists.