Appeal denied for man convicted in 2019 murder in Airdrie, Alta.
The Alberta Court of Appeal has denied the request of an Airdrie man to set aside his murder conviction in the fatal shooting of his neighbour in 2019.
Michael Antony Roebuck was convicted of first-degree murder in 2022 and sentenced to life in prison for the brutal slaying of Daniel MacDonald, his former friend, on Sept. 7, 2019.
According to testimony heard at trial, the pair of men had known each other for about five years, but "their relationship changed" when they decided to start a cannabis operation together.
A conflict began over the harvesting of the marijuana, descending into accusations from Roebuck that MacDonald was stealing supplies of the drug from him.
"Mr. Roebuck became increasingly hostile and aggressive," the court documents said, attributing part of his behaviour on a drug dependence that began after he was injured in a workplace accident.
"A neighbour said Mr. Roebuck told her that he had found someone 'to take care of Dan,' and on another occasion that 'something bad is going to happen to Dan.'"
- Sign up for breaking news alerts from CTV News, right at your fingertips
- The information you need to know, sent directly to you: Download the CTV News App
At 4:45 p.m. on Sept. 7, 2019, both men met each other at a gas station near where they lived.
The court heard that they got into a verbal argument, which led to a physical fight where MacDonald knocked Roebuck to the ground.
Roebuck left the gas station and arrived back at his home at 4:55 p.m., then went down to his basement to retrieve a "tactical" shotgun.
"He loaded the shotgun with five shells and walked back upstairs, shotgun in hand," the court document said. "Video footage shows that he re-entered his garage, leaving against his car while holding the shotgun, and looked outside the open garage door toward Mr. MacDonald's house."
When MacDonald returned a few minutes later, Roebuck left his garage and hid behind the Jeep that his victim was sitting in.
"When Mr. MacDonald got out of his truck, Mr. Roebuck stepped around the Jeep and confronted him, pushing the muzzle of his shotgun into Mr. MacDonald's face," officials said.
"He said Mr. MacDonald's attitude changed 'really fast' and he lowered the shotgun to point at Mr. MacDonald's abdomen."
During the trial, Roebuck testified that MacDonald grabbed the shotgun and pulled it toward himself, but the judge didn't believe that occurred.
"The evidence of the forensic pathologisy was that the shotgun was fired from about three to four feet away from Mr. MacDonald," the court said.
"Within two to five seconds," Roebuck shot the victim a second time as he was lying face down on the ground from about two to three feet away.
The trial judge found Roebuck fired two shots to ensure MacDonald was dead.
The court heard that Roebuck went back to his home and hid in some bushes in his backyard.
When RCMP arrived later, he eventually surrendered, telling them the killing wouldn't have happened if MacDonald hadn't punched him at the gas station.
'No reviewable error'
At his appeal hearing on April 11, Roebuck claimed the conviction was unreasonable because the Crown did not prove he intended to kill MacDonald.
During the appeal hearing, Roebuck said "a carefully thought-out scheme had to have been considered and weighed prior to implementation and time taken to contemplate the benefits and drawbacks of that plan before acting on it."
The appeal court disagreed, saying the trial judge made "no reviewable error."
"He calculated a scheme or design that he thought out over the course of driving home, going into the basement, retrieving the shotgun, suppressor or silencer, and ammunition, and sitting in his garage waiting for Mr. MacDonald to arrive.
"It was a simple and direct plan to kill Mr. MacDonald. It was not impulsive.
"Mr. Roebuck had 11 minutes to weigh the advantages and disadvantages of his intended action and he never deviated from it."
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
More Canadians only making minimum payment on credit cards: TransUnion
Some Canadians are seeing their credit card balances grow as the cost-of-living crisis and higher interest rates eat into household budgets, a new report shows.
Tornado touches down west of the Island of Montreal
Emergency services in the town of Rigaud, Que. are investigating after a tornado touched down shortly after 5:30 p.m. on Friday.
Teen was doing homework at family's Mississauga, Ont. restaurant when gunman opened fire: testimony
The 13-year-old sister of a young man killed in the attack on her family’s Mississauga restaurant in 2021 took the stand in a Brampton courthouse on Monday to describe the terrifying moments of coming under fire.
Tanks reach Rafah's centre as Israel presses assault despite global scrutiny
Israeli tanks reached the centre of Rafah for the first time on Tuesday, witnesses said, three weeks into a ground operation in the southern Gaza city that has sparked global condemnation.
What a CBSA strike could look like, according to an expert
Slowed or interrupted travel, the passing of goods and significantly restricted borders should be expected if Canadian border workers take upcoming strike action.
Arm of mummy came off after mishandling by museum staff: Mexican government
Mexico's federal archaeology agency on Monday accused the conservative-governed city of Guanajuato of mistreating one of the country’s famous mummified 19th century bodies.
Five of Ontario's top 10 worst roads are located in the Toronto area
A new pothole-riddled street in Hamilton has taken the top spot for the worst road in Ontario, according to a new list released by the Canadian Automotive Association (CAA) on Tuesday.
DEVELOPING In Trump's hush money trial, prosecutors and defence lawyers are poised to make final pitch to jury
Prosecutors and defence lawyers in Donald Trump's hush money trial are set to deliver closing arguments to the jury Tuesday, each side looking to score final points with the panel before it starts deliberating the fate of the first former American president to be charged with felony crimes.
Red Lobster in Ontario court to discuss U.S. bankruptcy case, Canadian assets: docs
A lawyer for Red Lobster Canada, Inc. says he will ask an Ontario court today to recognize and enforce the chain’s U.S. bankruptcy protection proceedings, a process which documents show could include selling Canadian assets.