Alberta utilities watchdog denies company's offer of 'refund' on consumer bills
Alberta's utilities watchdog has shut down a plan from a power transmission company to give ratepayers a refund, saying the small cash payout proposed by AltaLink would ultimately cost consumers millions more than it returned.
"AltaLink's proposal would not result in a just and reasonable tariff even though it would provide Alberta's electricity customers with some modest relief on their electricity bills," says the decision from the Alberta Utilities Commission.
"AltaLink's proposal would immediately require … customers to pay back its 'refund' with interest and carrying charges over the next 46 years."
The decision, released Friday, comes after AltaLink — Alberta's largest electricity transmitter — twice asked the commission for permission to give consumers a refund. AltaLink said the opportunity for a refund was generated by slower-than-expected depreciation of some company assets.
"Alberta consumers are feeling the pressure of high energy prices on electricity bills,” said AltaLink president Gary Hart in a May 2 press release. “Because we won’t require these funds for an extended period of time, we believe it makes more sense to put this $120 million back into the pockets of Albertans who need it most.”
AltaLink's proposal would have reduced the average household bill by $5 a month.
But the commission pointed out the refund would have been financed by a bank loan, not cash. With interest, carrying charges and other fees, the loan would have ultimately cost more than $250 million by the end of its term — all of which would have been recouped from consumers.
"There is no persuasive reason why future customers should pay higher electricity rates for 46 years given the modest relief in 2022," the commission wrote.
"AltaLink's proposal is more properly characterized as a loan. Refunds do not have to be paid back by the person receiving the refund."
The commission calculated that not only would the refund be paid back more than double by those who received it, AltaLink would likely record an $85-million profit over the life of the deal, the commission said. And it rejected the company's own accounting for the impact of the proposed refund.
"The review panel found AltaLink's assumptions … unreasonable and designed to achieve a result, namely to show a net present benefit to consumers."
The commission also said AltaLink's concerns over the impact of inflation on its customers was "in contrast" to its request to increase executive base pay by 10 per cent.
"While we’re disappointed that the Commission has reached this decision, we respect their position," said AltaLink spokesman Scott Schreiner.
"AltaLink remains focused on delivering solutions to reduce the cost of its service to customers. As part of its Flat for Five commitment, AltaLink has delivered on its promise to not raise its rates during this five-year period."
The Consumers' Coalition of Alberta appeared before the commission to oppose AltaLink's proposed refund.
"When you look at all the consequences, all the costs were greater than this short-term benefit," said lawyer Jim Wachowich.
Wachowich suggested the refund was an attempt by the company to position itself as helping consumers in a time of high inflation. A better approach, said Wachowich, would be for AltaLink and other utilities to reduce their profit expectations.
"They didn't want to do that."
Commission spokesman Geoff Scotton said the decision was final and represented AltaLink's last avenue of appeal, short of requesting a special hearing before the Alberta Court of Appeal.
This report by The Canadian Press was first published May 17, 2022.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
B.C. tenants evicted for landlord's use after refusing large rent increase to take over neighbouring suite
Ashley Dickey and her mother rented part of the same Coquitlam duplex in three different decades under three different landlords.
MPP Sarah Jama asked to leave Ontario legislature for wearing keffiyeh
MPP Sarah Jama was asked to leave the Legislative Assembly of Ontario by House Speaker Ted Arnott on Thursday for wearing a keffiyeh, a garment which has been banned at Queen’s Park.
Mountain guide dies after falling into a crevasse in Banff National Park
A man who fell into a crevasse while leading a backcountry ski group deep in the Canadian Rockies has died.
Body of Quebec man who died in Cuba found in Russia, family confirms
A Montreal-area family confirmed to CTV News that the body of their loved one who died while on vacation in Cuba is being repatriated to Canada after it was mistakenly sent to Russia.
Expert warns of food consumption habits amid rising prices
A new survey by Dalhousie University's Agri-Food Analytics Lab asked Canadians about their food consumption habits amid rising prices.
Saskatchewan isn't remitting the carbon tax on home heating. Why isn't my province following suit?
After Prime Minister Justin Trudeau said the federal government would still send Canada Carbon Rebate cheques to Saskatchewan residents, despite Saskatchewan Premier Scott Moe's decision to stop collecting the carbon tax on natural gas or home heating, questions were raised about whether other provinces would follow suit. CTV News reached out across the country and here's what we found out.
Montreal actress calls Weinstein ruling 'discouraging' but not surprising
A Montreal actress, who has previously detailed incidents she had with disgraced Hollywood producer Harvey Weinstein, says a New York Court of Appeals decision overturning his 2020 rape conviction is 'discouraging' but not surprising.
RCMP officers had no legal authority to enter man's home, make arrest: B.C. court
A B.C. man has been found not guilty of assaulting two RCMP officers – with the court finding he was resisting an "unlawful entry and arrest" in his home before he was tasered, taken down and hauled away in handcuffs.
'Deep ignorance': Calls for Manitoba trustee to resign sparked after comments about Indigenous people and reconciliation
A rural Manitoba school trustee is facing calls to resign over comments he made about Indigenous people and residential schools earlier this week.